The Book Club Blueprint: A Beginner’s Guide to Starting or Joining One

The Book Club Blueprint: A Beginner’s Guide to Starting or Joining One

There’s something magical about diving into a book and then discussing it with others who felt the same highs, lows, and plot twists. Whether you're a first-time reader looking for connection or a seasoned bibliophile craving community, the book club might just be your perfect literary escape.

But where do you begin? How do book clubs work, really? Do you need a velvet couch and trays of cupcakes to host one? (Hint: no, but snacks do help.)

Here’s your ultimate, beginner-friendly guide to starting or joining the book club of your dreams - along with tips, book club questions, and printable resources to make it seamless.

1. What Exactly Is a Book Club?

Let’s start with the basics: how do book clubs work?
At its core, a book club is a group of people who read the same book and then gather to discuss it. These discussions can range from structured (with a set list of book club questions) to casual conversations with tea and laughter.

Book clubs can be:

  • In-person (at homes, cafés, or libraries)
  • Virtual (Zoom, Google Meet)
  • Text-based (WhatsApp, Discord, Facebook Groups)

The vibe depends on the people - some book club people want deep dives into character arcs, while others are here for vibes and vibes only.

2. Why Join or Start a Book Club?

Still wondering whether it's worth your time? Here’s what book club people love most:

  • Accountability: You’ll actually finish your books.
  • Community: Great books spark even better conversations.
  • Discovery: You’ll read outside your usual genres.
  • Reflection: Great for journaling, self-growth, or even starting your own reading blog.

And honestly, there’s nothing more rewarding than discussing the choosing book and realizing how different readers saw different things.

3. Picking the Right Book (and the Wrong One)

Arguably the most important (and controversial!) part of hosting a book club is selecting the choosing book. A great pick leads to fiery debates and shared quotes. A bad one? You’ll hear the sound of collective eye rolls.

Tips to choose the right one:

  • Look for books with layered characters and moral dilemmas
  • Aim for <400 pages unless your group is hardcore
  • Avoid books that are too academic unless everyone’s in that mindset
  • Try a seasonal theme - like Fonts & Fables' Autumn Reading Challenge Printable for fall vibes

Need suggestions for the choosing book?

  • Before the Coffee Gets Cold - short, thoughtful, easy to discuss
  • The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo - scandal, glamor, and identity
  • The Midnight Library – time loops and regrets = great convo material

4. How to Start Your Own Book Club (Without the Stress)

Hosting a book club might sound intimidating, but it’s easier than you think. You don’t need a Pinterest-perfect home or a degree in literature.

Here’s how to get started:

Step 1: Choose Your Vibe

Will your club be chill or analytical? Will you snack while chatting? Will everyone take turns choosing the book club reads?

Step 2: Find Your People
Invite friends, family, neighbors - or post in community groups like local Facebook pages. Look for book club people who share your reading energy.

Step 3: Set the Rules (Softly)

  • How often will you meet? (monthly is common)
  • Will you follow a theme?
  • How will the choosing book process work - vote, rotate, or host’s choice?

Step 4: Use Printables & Trackers

Use Fonts & Fables' Reading Journal Pages to jot down thoughts, book club questions, and your personal takeaways. It keeps the experience memorable and helps you contribute confidently during discussions.

5. Thoughtful Book Club Questions to Spark Conversation

Whether you're joining or hosting a book club, it's helpful to have a list of book club questions ready to guide the chat. These keep things flowing when everyone’s sipping tea and staring at each other.
Here are a few evergreen options:

  • What was your first impression of the main character?
  • Did the ending surprise you or feel satisfying?
  • What quote stuck with you?
  • Would you recommend this to a friend? Why or why not?
  • How did the book make you feel?

Pro Tip: Print out 5–7 questions for every meeting and rotate who brings them each time!

6. Virtual or In-Person? Why Not Both?

The beauty of the book club today is that it doesn’t have to be bound by location. You can create a hybrid club with virtual chats + in-person meetups once in a while.

Virtual tools for book clubs:

  • Google Meet or Zoom
  • Google Forms for voting on the choosing book
  • Shared Google Docs for everyone to add their book club questions
  • WhatsApp/Telegram for reminders and banter

7. Make It Fun with Themes and Challenges

Want to make your club stand out? Add fun elements like:

  • Book Challenges (Fonts & Fables has gorgeous TBR & Tea Kit for adults)
  • Costume themes (wear something inspired by the book)
  • Quote sharing
  • Pairing snacks with settings - French pastries for Paris-set books, anyone?

Your goal as a host isn’t just hosting a book club, but curating a memorable experience.

8. Keeping the Group Engaged (aka No Ghosting)

After the excitement of the first meeting, life gets in the way. Here’s how to keep your book club members engaged:

  • Send gentle reminders 5–7 days before meetings
  • Share a fun teaser question in the group chat
  • Post quotes or polls in between
  • Switch up the genres or the choosing book style monthly

Also: celebrate small wins! Finished three books? Share a cute printable bookmark from Fonts & Fables as a reward.

9. What If You’re Just Joining One?

Not ready to host? No worries. Here’s how to get the most out of joining the book club:

  • Participate actively - even if you haven’t finished the book
  • Be respectful of different opinions
  • Don’t stress over missing one meeting
  • Use a printable tracker to jot down your thoughts (it helps with shy speakers!)

A good book club can turn strangers into lifelong friends. All it takes is showing up with your thoughts and an open mind.

Final Thoughts: Ready to Start Your Book Club Chapter?

Whether you're leading or joining, the book club experience is equal parts community and curiosity. With a few thoughtful tools, some inspired book club questions, and the right vibe, you’ll find yourself looking forward to every meeting.

And remember - there’s no one way to run a book club. The best ones are built on shared love for reading and a willingness to explore, question, and laugh together.

Get started with Fonts & Fables’ printables to elevate your book club journey:

So grab your book, gather your people, and let the pages turn - together.

Back to blog